I really disliked Katherine McPhee and wasn't crazy about Melissa O'Neill but Eva is growing on me.  Last week's song was really good and so was this weeks.  Then again we totally disagree on Chad - he's definitely my favourite of the top 10 this year.

 

Kim

 

On 8/15/06, happiblues <happyblue@...> wrote:

Performance grades:

Craig: A-
Ashley: B-
Chad: C+
Steffi: A
Eva: A
Tyler: B

Comments: Three points.

- After tonight's performance, Eva officially tops Katharine
McPhee and last year's CI winner, Melissa O'Neil, in the cool department.

- I want Steffi D's CD collection.

- Zack seems to be the only judge advising the contestants to think
beyond the scope of this show. The rest of the judges seem like yes
men, giving random praise to just about anyone.

Predicted boot: Steffi (too unique)