Errr my conversation with YOU was closed.. I was replying to Rachel so have a go at Rachel? lol

----- Original Message -----

From: Dancing Duade

To: The_X_Factor_ITV@yahoogroups.com

Sent: Friday, November 25, 2005 7:13 PM

Subject: Re: [The_X_Factor_ITV] Re: Chenai, 4Tune, Addictiv Ladies & Philip - All Rubbish

I thought this conversation was closed?  And Kaf, who
said 4Tune or any other artist were arrogant?
Certainly not me.  Oh and it was you who said "I rest
my case" when you talked about seeing 4Tune live - yes
I did see 4Tune sing live - on the X-Factor.

--- Connie Gurney <connie@...>
wrote:

> http://www.4tuneworld.co.uk/main
>
> There are currently 34 users and 77 guests online..
> that is a lot for a website  :)
>   ----- Original Message -----
>   From: Rachel Matthews
>   To: The_X_Factor_ITV@yahoogroups.com
>   Sent: Friday, November 25, 2005 6:56 PM
>   Subject: Re: [The_X_Factor_ITV] Re: Chenai, 4Tune,
> Addictiv Ladies & Philip - All Rubbish
>
>
>   I AGREE 4TUNE R RUBBBISH
>
>   kAf <kath_eckford@...> wrote:
>     Bhahahah
>     the ' i rest my case' strikes again!! :D
>     i just really hate it when people call 4tune
> arrogent, or any artist for that matter without
> knowing them the opinions not really valid..
>     i thought tabby was an arrogent arse till i met
> him again the other day and hes the nicest bloke
> ever :)
>
>     Dancing Duade <dancingduade@...> wrote:
>       How come you only pick up on one aspect of
> this
>       conversation (i.e. my opinion in that 4Tune
> are not
>       good) and have not mentioned anything about
> Kaf saying
>       "I rest my case" before I did?  You accused me
> of
>       saying "I rest my case" and har ped on about
> that and
>       said I was stating this as fact but I notice
> you
>       haven't now had a go at Kaf when you now know
> who said
>       this first.  Why is this?  Why don't you know
> have a
>       go at Kaf and her opinion/fact? Just because I
> dont
>       like 4Tune does not give you any excuse to
> have a go
>       at me.  Kindly just give it a rest as it is
> not really
>       a very interesting conversation.
>
>       --- Connie Gurney
> <connie@...>
>       wrote:
>
>       > I beg your pardon I thought you said "4tune
> suck" my
>       > apologies if you said something more
> educated...
>       >
>       >
>       >
>       >   ----- Original Message -----
>       >   From: Dancing Duade
>       >   To: The_X_Factor_ITV@yahoogroups.com
>       >   Sent: Friday, November 25, 2005 5:53 PM
>       >   Subject: Re: [The_X_Factor_ITV] Re:
> Chenai, 4Tune,
>       > Addictiv Ladies & Philip - All Rubbish
>       >
>       >
>       > &n bsp; This is getting silly.  My own
> opinion is that
>       > 4Tune
>       >   were not good on the show - I certainly
> would not
>       > pay
>       >   money to see them sing live if I didnt
> think they
>       > were
>       >   good and from what I heard I thougght
> other acts
>       > were
>       >   better.  This is my opinion.  I have seen
> posts on
>       >   this site slagging off other acts which is
> clearly
>       > the
>       >   writer's own opinion and no-one then
> replies by
>       >   insulting the writer.  I dont appreciate
> being
>       >   insulted by other members of this site
> just for
>       >   expressing my opinion.  I have every right
> to say
>       > that
>       >   a band was not very good - 4Tune went on a
> talent
>       > show
>       >   and so knew that there would be criticisms
> and
>       >   compliments.  So kindly be adult enough t
> o let me
>       >   express my opinion and if you read the
> messages
>       > you
>       >   will see that Kaf said "I rest my case"
> before I
>       >   replied so Kaf was apparently stating a
> fact. 
>       >
>       >   And yes I do read the messages.  So the
> fact that
>       >   about 10 people seem to be the ones
> e-mailing
>       > about
>       >   4Tune saying they were good does not mean
> that the
>       >   rest of the country who like 4Tune didnt
> vote
>       > because
>       >   they also thought they were safe.  That
> could be
>       > said
>       >   for any act who has fans - fans of a
> particular
>       > act
>       >   will be more likely to think they sang
> well and
>       > better
>       >   than others simply because they are fans.
> This
>       > means
>       >   that you must vote if you like a
> particular act or
>       >   they could be voted off.  4Tune were in
> the bottom
>       > two
>       >   acts and it was the judges who had the
> final say
>       > so
>       >   that means on the night the public, either
> by
>       > deciding
>       >   they were not good (my opinion) or not
> voting as
>       > they
>       >   thought they were safe (your opinion),
> relegated
>       > them
>       >   to either 10th or 11th out of 11 acts.
> That is
>       > the
>       >   onnly fact in this case - everything else
>       > concerning
>       >   the singing merits of 4Tune is opinion
> which is
>       >   obvious to anyone reading my e-mails. 
>       >
>       >   --- Connie Gurney
>       > <connie@...>
>       >   wrote:
>       >
>       >   > P.s Too many  of us just thought they
> were
>       > safe..
>       >   > and didn't vote.. I was at work but I
> thought
>       > they
>       >  ;  > were safe where you been! Do you read
> this much?
>       >   >
>       >   >   ----- Original Message -----
>       >   >   From: Connie Gurney
>       >   >   To: The_X_Factor_ITV@yahoogroups.com
>       >   >   Sent: Thursday, November 24, 2005
> 10:49 PM
>       >   >   Subject: Re: [The_X_Factor_ITV] Re:
> Chenai,
>       > 4Tune,
>       >   > Addictiv Ladies & Philip - All Rubbish
>       >   >
>       >   >
>       >   >   Who you talking to dude? Excuse me but
> weren't
>       > you
>       >   > the one who stated 4Tune suck?
>       >   >   That is an educated opinion is it?
>       >   >   Were you not the one telling Kaf to
> not take
>       >   > things seriously... listen to yourself.
>       >   >
>       > &nb sp; >   You can't state an opinion and
> then say I rest
>       > my
>       >   > case to kaf.. Rest my case is basically
> saying
>       > that
>       >   > you have proven something.. you have
> not.. its
>       >   > opinion..
>       >   >
>
=== message truncated ===



           
___________________________________________________________
To help you stay safe and secure online, we've developed the all new Yahoo! Security Centre. http://uk.security.yahoo.com