Rules of the Game 1. Criticism. Serious, not serious, sound drubbings, round mockings, and utter gushing - all allowed. No, really. Gen, het, and slash...
CriticalEdge@yahoogro...
Sep 1, 2004 8:15 am
9546
Commentary w/screen captures can be found at: http://www.wordsmiths.net/MacGeorge/episodes/Season5/Innocence.htm COMMENTARY: Gilllian tells us she loves the...
... You know, what bothered me most about this episode was how *childish* Richie became when he ran away from Duncan: picking fights for no good reason, acting...
Obviously, I agree that Richie was quite unattractive in this episode. What surprised me is that there has been no response on any other lists (two of which...
Oddly, I think a lot of the Richie girls are in LotR and popslash fandoms now<g>. At least the ones I know. S:) ... From: "kageorge" <kageorge@...> To:...
I could *hear* the snark anyway<g> S:) ... From: "kageorge" <kageorge@...> To: <CriticalEdge@yahoogroups.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 07, 2004 1:38 AM ...
Hmph! It's not my fault if you read deep hidden meaning in perfectly reasonable, quite civilized (and accurate) commentary. MacG (feeling contentious today)...
I thought I killed you already with the bad poetry. *hmph* S:) ... From: "kageorge" <kageorge@...> To: <CriticalEdge@yahoogroups.com> Sent: Tuesday,...
Ahem. Well I like Richie, have right from the beginning. Not that I particularly want to slash him, mind you. Well, except with Gregor, maybe. *g* Alas, I ...
html version w/screen captures, at: http://www.wordsmiths.net/MacGeorge/episodes/Season5/Manhunt.htm COMMENTARY: Peter Ellis, the episode director, mentions...
Commentary w/screen captures at: http://www.wordsmiths.net/MacGeorge/episodes/Season5/GloryDays.htm COMMENTARY: Donna Lettow says that, over time, they tried...
Commentary w/screen captures at: http://www.wordsmiths.net/MacGeorge/episodes/Season5/DramaticLicense.htm COMMENTARY: David A. says this was one of their other...
I've never liked this episode either. It's the only one I never taped, and somehow always missed taping when it was rerun, so I was looking forward to seeing...
just wondering. after all, we know that Immortals can heal quickly anything (minor) that happens to them once they become Immortal. yet Immortals who, logic...
... Certainly Duncan has calluses, you can see that his hands are overly broad and muscular, but just because the other Immortals' calluses aren't immediately...
Last time on, Critical Edge, Rodlox asked about a lyric wheel. This time, we begin with Amand-r in the Batcave: Sure why not? Spread the word, sign ups for...
Hi. Newbie here. I've been lurking, reading the episode commentaries and it's obvious that people are putting quite a bit of thought into examining events in...
It's been played with a lot in fic, and the answers range from "This always happens when two Qs are in close proximity" to "It was Kronos trying to attack/join...
when Cassandra tried to convince Kronos that his sword was growing heavy...did he reply with the same hypnosis, or did he simply ignore her hypnotism? ...
... As I recall, he just ignored her, telling her it was useless to try that trick on him. That has led to speculation about whether age or power or something...
... ignore ... that ... oh. All I recall (and vaguely at that!) is that she said he's getting sleepy, sword getting heavy; and Kronos said "make love to me". ...
Commentary w/screen captures at: http://www.wordsmiths.net/MacGeorge/episodes/Season5/Haunted.htm COMMENTARY: Stan K. talks about how he (as Richie) was given...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
