... I agree, but only in part. In the *present*, Kronos lacks the subtlety of intellect to deal with replicating something approximating a group that manages...
... You have misquoted me, out of context. What I actually said was: ... that ... which ... You seem to have missed the part about *most likely* the Cassandra...
Donna Lettow and Gillian Horvath (two of the shows writers who are regularly on the con circuit) have shown some outtakes that are of Methos shoving Kronos...
... We don't know that. ... And I don't see an inconsistent pattern. I've never said Methos wasn't a strong, willful individual, perfectly capable of handling...
... I always got the sense that Methos was being obviously outrageous. And Joe knew it. And Methos knew that Joe knew. And it was a game for them that they...
... I think that Methos post Horsemen definitely eshewes the spotlight. And also sees the folly of being in a leadership position. i don't believe he thinks...
... to ... Yes, in fact, we *do* know that this is what I said. And it is in contrast to the way you previously misquoted me. If your intent is to argue with...
... knew it. And Methos knew that ... historian. And Joe was waiting to see ... maybe that's the kind of roundabout way ... Joe. He likes Joe, respects him and...
I am such a sweet person it would never occur to me to suggest that the participants in this increasingly personal and acrimonious thread get a room--at least...
I believe I have written more than enough fiction and commentary to adequately articulate my view of Methos' character. I prefer to let that speak for itself,...
... MacGeorge, if you intend this as a response to Taz (whose subject line you are replying under, and who was way out of line), then I certainly think it is a...
... Agreed. In canon, it's never specified that Kronos is the leader of the Horsemen. (Unless MacGeorge is taking this from outtakes which I haven't seen?)...
... *Thank you!* ... If she is, she didn't say so, but in any case outtakes aren't canon. ... She thinks they both need to die, that's true. And she does hate...
Does anyone know a good place to download Methos episodes. The quality off of Kazza is very bad and I don't get cable. If anyone finds anything I would...
... Actually they probably are difficult to replace. From the other flashback we have of Kronos, he was leading a band of mortals. My guess is that the "trash...
... I disagree. That is, I agree that the best way (indeed, the only way) to "win" an argument about interpretation of canon is to have your interpretation of ...
... Hmmm... well, that's arguable. Thanks to the films, the Eurominutes, and the known outtakes, Highlander has a lot of arguable is-it-canon-isn't-it-canon...
--On Sunday, November 2, 2003 11:22 AM +0000 Jane Carnall ... I actually think they're being a little more specific than just "a long time", though I doubt...
... Yes, I can see that! But to me it seems reasonable to say that with regard to the series the Eurominutes are the complete "director's cut" eps, i.e., ...
... Yeah, that makes sense. I hadn't thought of it in those terms. We've certainly seen plenty of evil immortals, but maybe you're right that those would be...
... Fanon is where group perception (almost like GroupThink) becomes so entrenched, so pervasive, and visible in so many fics, that even newcomers absorb the...
... There's no contradiction there. It just means that they took Cassandra toward the *beginning* of their career rather than at the end. Nothing in canon says...
COMMENTARY: BP tells us that after all the debate over the first one (I think he means the first two-parter), the audience seemed to like two part episodes...
... From: Jane Carnall To: CriticalEdge@yahoogroups.com Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2003 5:52 AM Subject: [CriticalEdge] Re: Canon Issues Have No Value...Unless...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
